Buttery Nipple Recipe Easy Layered Shot with Butterscotch and Cream

Looking to whip up a Buttery Nipple shot that’ll steal the show at your next party? This creamy, butterscotch-kissed cocktail is a crowd favorite, and we’ve got the ultimate guide to make it effortlessly. With just two ingredients and a few pro tips, you’ll master this sweet shot recipe in no time. I’ve poured years of mixology know-how into this simple yet irresistible party drink, so you can impress your guests without breaking a sweat. Ready to dive into the fun? Let’s shake things up!

What Is a Buttery Nipple Shot

The Buttery Nipple shot is a sweet, layered drink that first popped up in the 1980s. It quickly gained attention not just for its playful name but also for its delicious flavor combo. This shot mixes butterscotch schnapps with Irish cream to create a creamy, dessert-like treat that’s smooth and easy to enjoy. Its rich taste and fun appearance have made it a favorite at social gatherings, bachelorette parties, and holiday celebrations across the U.S.

Ingredients You’ll Need

For a classic Buttery Nipple shot, you’ll want these core ingredients:

• 1 oz Butterscotch Schnapps (like DeKuyper Buttershots)
• ½ oz Irish Cream Liqueur (Bailey’s is a popular choice)

To add some extra flair, try optional garnishes such as:

• Whipped cream
• A fresh raspberry
• A drizzle of caramel sauce

If you need substitutions, you can switch things up easily:

• Use caramel liqueur or vanilla vodka instead of butterscotch schnapps
• Try different Irish cream brands based on your taste or what you have on hand

Step-by-Step Instructions for a Perfect Buttery Nipple

1. Chill everything – Start by putting your shot glass and ingredients in the fridge or freezer for a bit. Cold ingredients help keep the layers separate.

2. Pour butterscotch schnapps – Add 1 oz of butterscotch schnapps (like DeKuyper Buttershots) into your chilled shot glass.

3. Layer Irish cream – Slowly pour ½ oz of Irish cream liqueur (Bailey’s works great) over the back of a spoon right above the schnapps. This helps create that classic layered look.

4. Add a finishing touch (optional) – Top it off with a dollop of whipped cream or place a raspberry on top to mimic the “nipple” effect.

Pro tip: Use a jigger for exact measurements and pour slowly to keep your layers neat and distinct.

Tips for Mastering the Layered Effect

To get that perfect look on your Buttery Nipple shot, follow these simple tips:

• Use cold ingredients: Chilling both the butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream helps keep the layers from blending together.
• Pour slowly over a bar spoon: Gently pour the Irish cream over the back of a spoon to create distinct, clean layers.
• Let it rest: Allow the shot to sit for 1–2 minutes so the layers can settle and look sharp before serving.

These easy steps make your layered shot look professional and taste just right.

Variations to Try

If you want to switch things up from the classic Buttery Nipple shot, here are some easy variations to try:

• Slippery Nipple: Swap the butterscotch schnapps for sambuca. It adds a licorice flavor twist that some people really enjoy.
• Buttery Finger: Add a splash of coffee liqueur for a richer, more boozy shot with a deeper flavor profile.
• Caramel Buttery Nipple: Use caramel vodka instead of butterscotch schnapps to give the shot a sweeter, caramel-forward taste.
• Cocktail Version: Double the ingredients and shake them with ice. Serve in a rocks glass for a smoother, sippable cocktail.
• Non-Alcoholic Option: Replace the schnapps with butterscotch syrup and use non-alcoholic Irish cream for a tasty, alcohol-free version.

These swaps keep things fun and let you customize the shot to your taste or occasion. For more simple drink ideas, you might also enjoy some of our easy mocktail recipes.

Perfect Occasions for a Buttery Nipple Shot

Buttery Nipple shots are a hit at holiday parties like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s, bringing a sweet, festive vibe everyone loves. They’re also perfect for bachelorette parties or birthday celebrations, adding a playful touch to the fun.

For more casual settings, these shots work great at game nights or girls’ nights in, offering a simple yet tasty drink option.

Pair your Buttery Nipple with chocolate desserts, macarons, or fruit tarts to complement its creamy, sweet flavors and impress your guests.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the alcohol content
The Buttery Nipple shot is usually around 15–17% ABV, making it a moderate-strength shot.

Can I make it ahead
Yes, you can mix it ahead and keep it in the fridge for up to 3 days. Just add any garnishes like whipped cream or a raspberry right before serving.

What if I can’t layer it
No worries—it still tastes great mixed together. Just shake it with ice for a smooth, blended version.

Is it gluten-free
This depends on the brands you use. For example, Bailey’s Irish Cream is gluten-free, but always double-check your butterscotch schnapps to be sure.

Why Aura Loves This Recipe

At Aura, we’re all about practical, joyful living, and the Buttery Nipple shot fits right in. It’s quick, affordable, and super easy to make with just a couple of ingredients anyone can find. Plus, it sparks creativity—you can switch up the flavors or add your own twist to match any taste. Whether you’re hosting a casual night in or a festive party, this recipe keeps things simple but fun, exactly how we like it.

Ready to Impress Your Guests

Give this Buttery Nipple recipe a try at your next party or casual hangout. It’s quick, fun, and sure to get some smiles. Once you’ve nailed the layers and enjoyed your shot, share your photos and tips with AuraLovesCocktails on Instagram. We love seeing how you make this sweet shot your own.

For more crowd-pleasers, check out related Aura favorites like Top 10 Party Cocktails for Easy Entertaining or Dessert Drinks to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth. These are perfect for making any occasion a little more special.